Wednesday, June 11, 2008

Now for the Saga of my overheating VTX





When purchasing my VTX I opted for the the Monsoon from Indmar since, my previous boat had the Indmar 350 carburated engine in an I-drive Moomba Outback. Now I had the Moomba for 10 years with a seasonal replace battery,starter,shaft packing and pump the boat always started and had very few issues till year 9 when I had the carb rebuilt. 
So now to my less that 25hr old Malibu that overheated all the time and had a surge in startup
 to add to my issues. On my 6th launch( probably the boat's 10th) from the worst trailer ever built into my lake which is admittedly low. While throttling it off the trailer as described by a manufactures customer service rep. the boat overheat blinking screen of doom came on saying OVERHEAT. So I shut it off as I float off in to the middle of my lake waiting for the boat to cool down . Now to review the boat has overheated 3 other times and I mentioned it in the first service ticket to the dealer(where they claimed to have changed a sensor???) Now I go to the dealer and call Malibu Customer service where I was blessed to have the good fortune to talk with Stephanie J who
 claimed in a second phone conversation with me where she says it was some how my fault and sides with my dealer who is telling me I must have destroyed my new boats pump. ( the Dealer says the same ) so I fold even knowing that I couldn't have, I play along. I get stuck buying it then pulling it and checking it on a new boat . This is like buying an new car and the dealer telling you to fix the water
 pump(just not right) Well the the pictures tell the story(not an easy picture to get) looked like when they built the boat.((A must have is a inline sediment filter thankfully I am smarter than the dealer and had one installed it gets the grass algie before it gets in the engine and is in a clear cylinder so it can be visually checked quickly.)) We checked it as well a little sand nothing more.
Now, After a not so funny e-mail from my dealer I call them where the dealer sends one of his best techs to do a dock side repair. His tech arrives and looks into the over heating and a new problem a random popping(sounds like popcorn) when the boat gets warm not hot. First as I had told the dealer the 90degree elbo hardware on the exhaust was loose and could be the problem(note made of plastic and I believe will be an ongoing issue) and it was part of it. Then we plug in his pc and motor around for a while to recreate the popping noise and we do as well as check for overheating. The Tech spent 3 hrs on this and felt it was fixed and recorded the data from my boat popping to send to Indmar support.(I think they may want to switch to mac since the data collected on their pc was corrupted no help from Indmar)
Then my nephews arrive and of course they want to go on the boat not more than 10 minutes on the water it starts with the Doom notifications of overheating and add a new one which I 
expected from the beginning ECU(electronic control unit)failure. Oddly the boat would be hard and at one point had to be tricked into restarting to allow me to get back to the dock. On one occasion in the same session the boat started ran and would have the screen flashing the above message.
Well as with everything on this boat it's a fight, I take my nephew and his friend with me to the dealer and discuss the issue and he then tells me well we as a industry have had many issues and a high failure rate with these MMDC
 modules and it controls everything on the engine and gauges. 
So he sends a tech out late on a saturday to his credit and they replace the module and feel they have it right. Except now apparently a missing gasket on the afore mentioned filter may cause more problems. I found the missing gasket and wasn't sure where it came from but later installed it as instructed by the dealer.
After 4 weeks of this I'm happy to report  the boat seems to run great still a little uneasy about the throttle surge at start up. Once again the dealer says that's normal but the last time I started any of my cars none of them surge up and down. 

Monday, June 2, 2008

For the Repair ........ Not even close

Now below in red is the first E-mail sent directly to my service advisor at my dealer with problems and concerns before my first service along with a short group of questions that were latter sent to Malibu Corperate on the Mux Switches.  I also outlined issues with the Mux controllers that had no options or aux switch openings. Worth noting once again calling around finally led to the document with instructions on how to change around controls. Why Malibu doesn't put that film crew to work on a DVD showing how to adjust and use everything on this boat is a mystery to me instead a fluff dvd of pros wakeboarding.
Got a two page doc from the my Malibu dealer's lead tech showing how to modify the mux controls( not in my owners manual I checked) . Ok here are a few short comings
1) No instructions on how to add switch to blank spot
2)Switch options disappeared all together prior to editing I saw a front tower and rear tower switch only one shows up now.
3) No open aux switch options? for adding other powered accessories(lights on rear swim platform/other mood lighting(since tier is no place for other regular switches) ( I could use the switch called vent,I guess? still no documentation on your site or any where else)
4)No instructions on how to exit programing mode?
5) Why not add horn button to the steering wheel and free up 3 possible switch modes since the factory lighting options end up on 2 pages ( I gota believe every one would know where it is).

Hit list of problems not pictured
1)Dummy screws in table post
2)Dummy screw in rear compartment for 90 deegre brace
3)Loose nuts in right side gunnel area
4)tower super loose rattled like a 20 year old tower towing 300lbers instead of the hot little Arwyn weighing in at 103lb.
5)Same no tower stop needs adjustment other wise it sits on dash
6)Believe it or not one of the 2 screws holding the Led up in the storage area below glovebox is loose( I'm sure it's not alone)
7)Tons of butt connectors everywhere felt like they clipped down a harness from a vlx to fit
8)All of the accent lights joined with but connectors
9)When I removed malibu lit logo on right side,plastic was cracked before I got to it(very thin not very impressive). (can any one point me to your Led supplier so I can order blue leds to replace the red ones and since they are butt connected I know I will do a better job)
10) I expect Malibu to run and connect tower power leads into the medalion unit so all I need to do is install my bar and put fuses in.(I think it is inexcusable that the wires are not pulled and loomed to their desired locations like speaker wires from tower to stereo area and to medalion control box.
11) I also believe it is Malibu's responsibility to supply a solid place to mount my aftermarket head unit wether it be Sony or Alpine or Pioneer if i choose not to  get the JBL black box as well as a universal connector to control all major head units with the mux switches( since the only place to add third party controller is the glass). If you do get JBL Black box you need add a Mute on the remote  Mux controller so when you come around to verify rider is ok or offer instruction it's a simple tap away.
Fix the air tube hanging down in the front right gunnel in plain sight(it's just sad)

I have a few other issues
1) While the windshield is super cool I have a huge collection of dead love bugs in a place I can't get to but can see.
2)Trailer cover sucks ( if you try to put it on from inside the boat , many of my attempt have left me crawling under the cover going to the front and having to get the nose of the cover back on  and pulling it over the windshield is just plain hard. Once you get to the tower it's done as long as the wind doesn't blow) 
So that was the list and other than a service and a few token newer style heat shrink butt connectors.
What makes it worse is I went to pick it up and the service manager went into the boat and the few loose screws I actually mentioned weren't even touched as demonstrated in front of him. Then the tower issue he claimed was all-ready adjusted as best as it can be.  As my pictures will support the tower was over tightened and the gasket is worthless now, as well as being able to lifting it up and down I will video tape and demonstrate in latter blog entries. The dealer fix for the Loose tower rattle was a piece of foam and then they didn't even bother to put it in. the Dive platform lights were rewired to a switch called heater on the right bank. The tower lights were wired at an expense to me of a 150.00. Where Malibu clearly has slipped and is in denial since most of these features have existed for years on previous VLX's that had the mux controller.

Quality for which Malibu Based their reputation On





Now I have a refund check for my JBL in hand and want to install a radio/IPod controlled unit in my Malibu. Of course Malibu made no provisions for this so you guessed it either I kiss my glovebox good by or get creative with my storage locker where the my amps are.  
Now I proceed to remove the the Jbl and start working on my strategy for my stereo. Here where I get my first up close example of quality, Ready When I pull the panel in the storage area away their is the radio connected by what appears to be a bunch of butt crimp connectors(understand that this is still a unsealed electrical connection when moisture from the air gets in it can corrode and destroy the connection most marine installers will solder and heat shrink their connection) and then on top of that a huge ball of wire from the Usb/Mini audio connector at least 20ft of wire(see Pic) (someone didn't order the right length) Not excited so far then go to the drivers side to run a sub wire when I see even more butt connectors and even better a very large 4 ga positive feed wire sitting on the ground strip spade connectors ready to wear it away and eventually shorting out the entire electrical system(see Pic).
Along with this I find numerous loose screws all over the boat keep in mind the boat was only 5-7hrs old and I was already enjoying my new boat being on my back having to put a stereo in since the factory one was a dud and no fix on the horizon. This is only the start.....